Smithmodified sgarbossa criteria and paced rhythms. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria ecg medical training. The first thing you have to do is determine the direction of the major qrs deflection. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 1. The picture above is the best illustration i could find.
Stephen smith presented a set of modified sgarbossa criteria, hoping to increase the sensitivity of this tool, while still maintaining a. The criteria of stsegment depression in v1, v2 or v3 had similar test characteristics to sgarbossas study sensitivity of 19%, specificity of 81% compared with a sensitivity of 29% and specificity of 82% in sgarbossas study. The sgarbossa criteria consist of st segment elevation of 1 mm or more concor dant with the qrs complex i. The first complex above is up, the second is down and the third is.
The sgarbossa criteria help with that determination. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left. Increases sn from 52% 91% at the expense of reducing sp from 98% 90% sgarbossa original criteria. Acute myocardial infarction, ami, lbbb, left bundle branch block, modified sgarbossa criteria, sgarbossa criteria, stemi one comment. However, there is a growing body of literature that suggests that these criteria can also be applied for the diagnosis of stemi in patients with paced rhythms. Performance characteristics of the modified sgarbossa criteria. The sgarbossa and smithmodified sgarbossa criteria have been documented to enhance the diagnosis of stemi in the setting of lbbbs.
Jacc 2012 proposed that newpresumed lbbb should not be considered a stemi equivalent. In this final part of the series id like to talk about smiths modification to sgarbossas criteria and the importance of serial ecgs. Sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction cmaj. Of course, we can apply criteria of sgarbossa to differentiate. A large clinical trial of thrombolytic therapy for. Sgarbossa e, pinski s, et al for the gusto1 investigators.
The third aspect of the rule was altered so that instead of an absolute height of st elevation of 5mm or more, the ratio of st deviation up or down to the s wave of 0. St elevation 1 mm and in the same direction concordant with the qrs complex. Figure 2, figure 3 show repeat ecgs done 3 and 4 h after the first ecg. If you recall there are two main problems with using 5 mm as an arbitrary cutoff for discordant stelevation in the presence of left bundle branch block. The sgarbossa criteria consist of stsegment elevation of 1 mm or more. Pdf application of smithmodified sgarbossa criteria assessment. Modified sgarbossa first 2 criteria are the same as with sgarbossa st segment elevation of 1 mm or more if in same direction concordant as qrs complex in any lead. Enhancing the sgarbossa criteria for the diagnosis of st. Specificity of the modified criteria was not statistically different from the original weighted criteria 99% vs 100%, p. In 1996 sgarbossa et al 3 identified three ekg criteria that may improve the diagnosis of stemi in patients with left bundle branch block 1. Sgarbossa criteria background in patients with left bundle branch block lbbb or ventricular paced rhythm, infarct diagnosis based on the ecg is difficult.
The sgarbossa criteria sc are a validated set of three highlyspecific ecg criteria commonly used to diagnosis acute myocardial infarction in nonpaced. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 2. Editor,we read with interest the paper about the electrocardiographic diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction ami in patients with left bundle branch block lbbb. Sgarbossa criteria comprise three electrocardiographic criteria for diagnosis of acs in patients with lbbb. In 1996, sgarbossa et al26 published an analysis from the gusto1 trial evaluating different ecg criteria to diagnose ami in the presence of lbbb. The modified criteria were unweighted any positive criterion was considered a stemi, with the first two ecg findings the same as the original sgarbossa rule. Std 1 mm in same direction as qrs in leads v1, v2, or v3. Sgarbossa criteria and modified sgarbossa criteria healthpam. Several characteristics of the paced ecg were predictive of ami. St segment depression of 1 mm or more in any lead from v1 to v3. Its often difficult to identify an mi for patients with existing left bundle branch blocks lbbb.
The presence of deep t wave inversions in leads with a predominantly negative. Identifying stemi in the presence of lbbb sgarbossas. A modified criteria could be based on the ratio between the s wave deflection and the corresponding st elevation. Em in 5 blog is a series of 5 minute emergency medicine lectures on high yield topics. In the original sgarbossa criteria, a score of download fulltext pdf sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction article pdf available in canadian medical association journal 18815 april 2016 with 623 reads. The left bundlebranch block puzzle in the 20 stelevation. The sgarbossa criteria can be used to identify patients who have acute myocardial infarction ami in the presence of left bundle branch block, which obscures the usual changes associated with st elevation myocardial infarction. The sgarbossa electrocardiography criteria are the most validated tool to aid in the diagnosis of stemi in the presence of lbbb. Left bundle branch block presents a dilemma for many clinicians in the evaluation of chest pain or other signs and symptoms of acs and its easy to see why. This is shown in the following picture based on dr stephen smiths description of a modified sgarbossas criteria.
Myocardial infarction diagnosis in the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb or ventricular paced rhythm. Figure 2 shows resolution of the excessive discordance in lead i, and figure 3 shows excessive discordance in lead i and. This opens the possibility of missing a large percentage acute mis. The baseline st segments and t waves tend to be shifted in a discordant direction appropriate discordance, which can mask or mimic acute myocardial infarction. Validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria for acute coronary occlusion in the setting of left bundle branch block. Criteria to diagnose acute mi in patients with prior lbbb. After seeing this ecg, the diagnosis of acute stemi was made using the smithmodified sgarbossa criteria. Sgarbossas is a well accepted approach at determining which lbbb are having an mi. Modified sgarbossas criteria c putting it all together. Here is a graphic i created to help explain sgarbossas criteria for identifying acute myocardial infarction ami in the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb or paced rhythm. A brief description of how to identify an mi in the presence of lbbb and paced rhythm. Left bundle branch block and acute mi neeland, et al.
The presence of a lbbb makes the diagnosis of an acute mi challenging. Changes the 3rd rule of original sgarbossas criteria to be st depression or elevation discordant with the qrs complex and with a magnitude of at least 25% of the qrs. Gusto1 global utilization of streptokinase and tissue plasminogen activator for occluded coronary arteries investigators. Criteria for which the interobserver agreement was at least 0. Validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria for acute. The sgarbossa criteria consist of stsegment elevation of 1 mm or more concordant with the qrs complex i. Still, sgarbossa will struggle to differentiate an acute stemi in chronic lbbb from an acute lbbb in old awmi. The validated smithmodified sgarbossa criteria msc have high sensitivity sens and specificity spec. Sgarbossas criteria are a set of electrocardiographic findings generally used to identify. Electrocardiographic diagnosis of evolving acute myocardial infarction in the presence of leftbundle branch block. Pdf sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction.
Pdf a 63yearold man presented to the emergency department. The validated smith modified sgarbossa criteria msc have high sensitivity sens and specificity spec. Sgarbossa criteria in bundle branch blocks and paced. The sgarbossa ecg criteria are the most validated tool. Conflicts of interest comprise financial interests, activities, and relationships within the past 3 years including but not limited to employment, affiliation, grants or funding, consultancies, honoraria or payment, speakers bureaus, stock ownership or options, expert testimony, royalties, donation of medical.
This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the sgarbossas criteria article. Acute myocardial infarction in patients with left bundle. With most lbbbs there is what is called appropriate disconcordance. Incomplete left bundle branch block lbbb is often under diagnosed by clinicians due to lack of. Identify all potential conflicts of interest that might be relevant to your comment. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 3. Sgarbossas criteria for mi in left bundle branch block. Discussion with a cardiologist should precede activation of the cath lab. A 84yearold man presents to the ed with chest pain 6 days after pci where he received a stent to his lad. Validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria core em. Please sign and date your posts by typing four tildes. Pronunciation of sgarbossa with 2 audio pronunciations, 1 translation and more for sgarbossa.
The original, weighted, sgarbossa criteria sgarbossa 1996 has an excellent specificity at 99%, but only a sensitivity of about 50%. Diagnosis of stelevation myocardial infarction in the. This is not a forum for general discussion of the articles subject. Patient has concordant st segment changes sgarbossa rules a or b. Patients with ventricular paced rhythm have ecg changes with similar morphology to left bundle branch block. In a previous article i showed this graphic which was created using powerpoint. In 1996, sgarbossa et al looked through the gusto1 trial patients with lbbb and ami. They derived 3 criteria which may help diagnose the hidden ami. The 12lead ecg is the cornerstone for diagnosing acute stsegment elevation mi stemi and should be obtained and interpreted as soon as the acute coronary syndrome is suspected so that appropriate therapy can be initiated. An initial bedside 12lead ecg revealed excessive discordance, with sts ratio of 33% in lead i.
427 353 388 313 269 1476 1457 811 1504 367 40 1172 364 1497 790 586 1321 1522 335 725 1057 404 369 628 269 191 803 259 1350 709 1517 1471 1458 383 1112 1445 756 963 1239 839 602 1073 702 1289 899 73 260